Attorney: Brennan Clay
Case Type: Commercial Trucking Collision
Outcome: $1,000,000 Settlement

‍

Witherite Law Group successfully resolved a commercial trucking collision case for $1,000,000, delivering a strong outcome for a client who suffered significant injuries after a preventable lane‑change crash involving two commercial vehicles.

The case required persistence through disputed liability, pre‑existing history, and multiple attempts by the defense to undervalue the claim before mediation.

‍

The Collision

The wreck occurred while our client was operating an 18‑wheeler for work when another commercial driver drifted out of his lane and collided with her truck.

Following the initial impact, the defendant driver lost control of his vehicle, veered off the highway, crossed an access road, and ultimately came to rest in a ditch.

While the defense initially suggested the collision may have been caused by a tire blowout, further investigation told a different story.

‍

Liability and Investigation

The investigative team conducted a detailed review of the wreck, including video evidence and accident reconstruction analysis. That investigation showed:

  • The defendant’s initial movement into our client’s lane was inconsistent with a tire failure
  • The tire damage occurred after the impact, not before
  • Eyewitness testimony was uncertain and did not support the defense’s version of events

This combination of evidence helped clarify responsibility and strengthened the case significantly.

‍

Injuries and Impact

Our client sustained injuries that required evaluation and ongoing treatment, including symptoms consistent with a mild traumatic brain injury, as well as neck and shoulder conditions.

The case was supported by medical documentation and expert evaluation, helping establish the connection between the crash and her condition.

‍

Settlement Process

The case went through multiple rounds of negotiation. At the first mediation, the defense offered no more than $125,000 and took the position that they would not consider a seven‑figure resolution.

Rather than accept that valuation, the legal team continued to develop the case and moved forward.

At the second mediation, the strength of the evidence, expert support, and sustained pressure began to shift negotiations in our favor. The case ultimately resolved for $1,000,000, aligning with our evaluated value range.

The client made the decision to settle, bringing the case to a close and allowing her to move forward with further healing.  

‍

A Team Effort

This result reflects the work of a coordinated litigation team, including:

  • Brennan Clay, who led the case strategy and negotiations
  • Team members supporting expert coordination, case development, and discovery
  • Investigation efforts that helped clarify liability and counter early defense claims

Each step of the case contributed to building the leverage needed to achieve a meaningful resolution.

‍

Our Commitment

Cases involving commercial vehicles often come with competing narratives, complex histories, and early efforts to minimize their value. At Witherite Law Group, we stay focused on the facts, continue developing the case, and push forward until the outcome reflects the full picture.

We are proud of the work that led to this result and remain committed to advocating for individuals injured in commercial trucking collisions.