Attorney: Victor Rodriguez

‍Case Type: Commercial Bobtail Truck Wreck  

‍Type of Wreck: Running a Stop Sign

‍Outcome: $985,491.88 Settlement
‍

Witherite Law Group successfully resolved a bobtail truck collision case involving a mother and her two minor children for $985,491.88, representing the remaining policy limits available. The settlement was reached after focused litigation, early investigation, and sustained pressure on the defense.

‍

The Crash

The collision occurred when a bobtail truck ran a stop sign and struck the client’s vehicle as it entered the intersection. The impact caused significant damage to the family’s vehicle and left little doubt as to responsibility.

Although the crash report supported the client’s account, the truck driver claimed the incident was unavoidable and insisted that both vehicles reached the intersection at the same time. The defense maintained this position despite physical evidence to the contrary.

‍

Early Investigation and Liability Evidence

Early liability work proved critical. The legal team obtained and analyzed data from the client’s vehicle, which showed a significant lateral force on the driver’s side. Based on reconstruction analysis, the data demonstrated that:

  • The truck did not stop at the stop sign, and
  • The truck entered the intersection at an estimated 19–24 miles per hour

This objective evidence directly contradicted the driver’s account and supported the conclusion that the collision was preventable.

During deposition, the defendant continued to deny running the stop sign, even when confronted with the data and other evidence. His testimony remained inconsistent, which further strengthened the case against him and the company.

‍

Litigation Strategy

Suit was filed early to preserve evidence and move discovery forward. The defense repeatedly delayed and resisted producing key documents, requiring the filing of a motion to compel, which ultimately resulted in the production of the information needed to fully evaluate liability and exposure.

As discovery progressed, the legal team:

  • Identified inconsistencies in the driver’s account of the crash
  • Uncovered prior incidents that had not been fully disclosed
  • Developed expert reports supporting liability and damages
  • Prepared the case with the expectation it would proceed to trial

The pressure created by discovery rulings, deposition testimony, and expert analysis set the stage for meaningful settlement discussions.

‍

Settlement and Resolution

After depositions were completed and the defense had the opportunity to fully evaluate the evidence, the case resolved for $985,491.88, representing the remaining available liability limits.

The settlement brought closure to the matter without the need for trial and reflected the strength of the liability case developed through early and persistent legal work.

‍

A Legal Team Effort

This result was achieved through coordinated work by the legal team, including:

  • Attorneys managing discovery, depositions, and motion practice
  • Team members analyzing evidence, vehicle data, and liability materials
  • Litigation support coordinating deadlines, filings, and expert preparation

Each phase of the case reflected careful planning, consistent follow‑through, and sustained effort to advance the matter toward resolution.

‍

Our Commitment

Cases involving commercial vehicles and families often require early action, careful investigation, and persistence when the facts are disputed. At Witherite Law Group, we focus on building strong liability cases, addressing resistance through the courts when necessary, and pursuing outcomes that reflect accountability.

‍

Want to read more about how we fight for our clients? Explore our case stories and follow us for more trial wins and firm updates.