At Witherite Law Group, this is why we do what we do. Big or small cases, they all matter. We have many

cases, but our clients have one. Each case is the most important case to our clients and their families.

However, there are times when you can make a monumental impact on a family that has suffered an

unimaginable tragedy. Mohamed and Nicole Fall were such a case.

Case Breakdown: $18.85M Settlement for Mohamed & Nicole Fall

Witherite Law Group is proud to share a powerful result for Mohamed and Nicole Fall - an $18.85

million settlement that reflects the gravity of what they endured and the strength they have shown.

This case wasn’t just about numbers. It was about honoring the humanity of two incredible people and

fighting for the justice they deserved.

The Collision

In Jefferson, South Carolina, a commercial truck driver, ran a stop sign at high speed and collided with

Mr. Fall’s tractor-trailer. Despite Mr. Fall’s attempt to avoid the crash, the impact sent his vehicle off the

road, where it overturned.

Liability was clear. The defendants admitted fault in their answer. We secured drive cam footage from

the commercial truck and surveillance video from a nearby gas station to confirm the sequence of

events.

The Impact

Mohamed and Nicole Fall came to the U.S. in the early 90s in pursuit of the American Dream. Mohamed

built a beautiful life with his wife, Nicole, and their two kids in Florence, South Carolina. Bringing him

freedom, independence, and stability, Mohamed loved his career as a tractor-trailer driver. He loved

playing soccer, cherished his role as a husband and father, and was active in his local community. Mrs.

Fall was a licensed mental health counselor. She loved her profession and life as a wife and mother. The

wreck changed everything.

Mohamed Fall suffered a devastating C6 cervical spinal cord fracture, leaving him a quadriplegic with

significant motor and sensory deficits in all four limbs. He also sustained a tibia fracture, pulmonary

embolism, and rib fractures. His life changed overnight.

Nicole Fall became her husband’s full-time caregiver while working two jobs to support their family.

Their dreams of travel, freedom, and retirement were erased.

Building the Case

We approached this case with empathy and precision, utilizing every available tool to tell the Falls’ story

and quantify the damages.

Visual Storytelling:

  • Day in the Life Videos: Scott Mottern from CRASH Media Productions captured deeply moving footage of Mr. and Mrs. Fall in their home and community. These videos were instrumental during mediation.
  • Medical Animations: Ryan Whitaker and Hannah Forward from CRASH Media Productions created detailed visuals of Mr. Fall’s injuries and surgeries, including spinal fusion, corpectomy, and tibia repair.

Expert Analysis

• Reconstruction Expert: Inspected the scene and vehicles to confirm the mechanical integrity of

the Mohamed tractor-trailer and collision dynamics.

  • Life Care Planner: Projected $3.5M in future medical and care needs.
  • Vocational Expert: Determined Mr. Fall had no capacity to work in any field.
  • Economist: Built a $5.5M economic damages model, including $1M in lost earning capacity.

Focus Group Testing

Litigation Laboratories, led by Suzanne Davis, helped focus group this case, and pulled participants from

the counties in the Florence Division. Their feedback helped refine the trial themes and revealed a

potential verdict of $10 million. Overall, improving the case value.

The Result

After extensive mediation and negotiation, led by Glenn Ingham, the Falls will recover over $10 million

personally. The total settlement reached $18.85 million.

This outcome reflects the gravity of their loss and the strength of their story. It’s a testament to what

happens when legal strategy meets compassion.

Teamwork in Action

This case was made possible by a dedicated team:

  • Lead Attorney: William Pate
  • Litigation Support: Leisha Chandler, Serenity Whitfield, Abbie Gholston, Ashley Jackson, Cynthia Brinson, Rosie Martinez, Darri’el Hannah
  • Negotiation Lead: Glenn Ingham
  • Visuals & Media: CRASH Team – Scott Mottern, Hannah Forward, Ryan Whitaker

Final Thoughts

Witherite Law Group believes in leading with integrity, executing with expertise, and making a lasting

impact. This case is a powerful example of those values in action.

Justice isn’t just about compensation—it’s about restoring dignity, honoring stories, and standing beside

our clients when they need us most.

Expertise Matters. You Matter.