The Power of Strategy: How Facts and Advocacy Secured Justice

At Witherite Law Group we believe every trial is an opportunity to uphold justice and protect those who rely on us. In Cook County, our team faced a complex case involving disputed liability, conflicting testimonies, and significant pre-existing medical conditions. Through preparation, precision, and unwavering advocacy, we delivered a verdict that speaks volumes.

When Facts and Strategy Prevail: A Cook County Trial Victory

This case involved a collision at a busy intersection, where the defendant claimed to have a green light and even suggested the traffic signals were malfunctioning. Adding to the complexity, our client had significant pre-existing conditions, including end-stage osteoarthritis in both knees and degenerative disc disease in her back.

Challenges Faced

  • Defendant asserted he had a green light and blamed signal malfunction.
  • Our client had extensive prior medical history and workers’ compensation records indicating chronic conditions.
  • Defense relied on expert opinions attributing all pain to pre-existing conditions.

Key Facts That Turned the Case

  • Our client was a rear-seat passenger being transported for work.
  • Dashcam footage from the vehicle provided clear evidence of liability and impact severity.
  • Defendant had pled guilty to a citation for failure to reduce speed.
  • A CDOT employee confirmed the lights were functioning properly, despite minor bulb issues.
  • Bodycam footage visually demonstrated proper signal cycling.
  • Eyewitness testimony unraveled under scrutiny, revealing inconsistencies.

Trial Execution

Alex Evans delivered a masterful opening, setting themes that dismantled the defense’s promises by closing. Her closing argument painted a vivid picture for the jury, exposing flaws in the defense’s narrative and allowing jurors to truly empathize with our client’s experience.

Behind the scenes, the trial team worked tirelessly:

  • Christopher Provost played a vital role in pre-trial motions, theme development, and in-court objections.
  • Jibraeel Zaidi contributed invaluable insights for voir dire and argument strategy.
  • Sarah Coix ensured flawless case management and logistics.
  • Sam Coletta , in her first trial, coordinated witnesses and experts with precision.
  • Luis Castaneda provided rapid juror research remotely.
  • Carlos Barrios oversaw courtroom technology seamlessly.
  • Malina Baer managed video edits and media under tight deadlines.

The Outcome

Despite a last-minute offer of policy limits, we proceeded to verdict, and the jury delivered a result that exceeded expectations. Post-verdict, the defense confirmed an assignment of claims against the insurer, paving the way for pursuing excess judgment and potential bad faith claims.

This case reflects what defines Witherite Law Group, strategic thinking, relentless preparation, and respect for the courtroom process. From navigating complex medical histories to dismantling testimonies, our team ensured the truth prevailed.